There’s nothing quite like indulging in a scoop (or two) of delicious, creamy ice cream on a warm, sunny day at the beach. Whether you’re looking for a classic cone, a refreshing frozen treat, or a decadent sundae, Anna Maria Island offers a variety of ice cream shops that are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth.
At Once Upon A Beach, we want to ensure your island stay is filled with all the delightful experiences that make a vacation unforgettable. One of the best ways to cool down after a day of sun and sand is by treating yourself to some of the island’s finest ice cream. From classic homemade flavors to unique artisanal creations, here’s our guide to the best ice cream shops on Anna Maria Island.
1. Two Scoops Ice Cream & Coffee Shop
- Location: 101 S Bay Blvd, Anna Maria
Conveniently located near the Anna Maria City Pier, Two Scoops Ice Cream is a local favorite and a must-visit for anyone craving a sweet treat on the island. This charming, family-owned shop serves up a wide variety of ice cream flavors—more than 30 to choose from—including classics like chocolate and vanilla, along with unique and seasonal flavors. Their generous portions and affordable prices make it a popular spot for both locals and visitors.
Beyond the ice cream, Two Scoops also offers coffee, milkshakes, and a variety of snacks, making it the perfect place to stop before or after exploring the pier. Grab your ice cream cone and take a leisurely stroll along the waterfront, enjoying the sea breeze as you savor every bite.
What to Try: Their Salted Caramel Pretzel and Toasted Coconut flavors are highly recommended for something different.
2. Small Town Creamery
- Location: 5404 Marina Dr, Holmes Beach
Small Town Creamery in Holmes Beach offers a whimsical and nostalgic ice cream experience. Step inside this retro-themed shop, and you’ll be greeted with an array of colorful ice cream options, frozen yogurt, and sorbets. Their creative and rotating selection of flavors will keep you coming back to try something new, and their fun toppings bar lets you personalize your treat with sprinkles, candy, and sauces.
The welcoming and kid-friendly atmosphere, combined with high-quality ice cream made with fresh ingredients, makes Small Town Creamery a great spot for families. If you’re looking for a relaxed, old-fashioned ice cream shop with a bit of flair, this is the place to be.
What to Try: The Cotton Candy flavor is a hit with kids, while adults might enjoy the rich Mocha Almond Fudge or Pistachio.
3. Dips Ice Cream
- Location: 503 Pine Ave, Anna Maria
Located on Anna Maria’s charming Pine Avenue, Dips Ice Cream is a fun and friendly shop that has been serving delicious frozen treats for over two decades. Known for its retro vibe and vibrant decor, Dips offers an extensive selection of ice cream flavors, including several dairy-free and sugar-free options. They even have nostalgic candy and frozen yogurt for those looking for something different.
After enjoying a day of shopping or biking along Pine Avenue, Dips is the perfect place to stop and cool off with a scoop of their homemade ice cream. Whether you prefer a cone, cup, or milkshake, Dips provides a variety of options to cater to every craving.
What to Try: Their Key Lime Pie ice cream perfectly captures the flavors of Florida, and the Superman flavor is always a colorful, fun choice for kids.
4. Hometown Desserts
- Location: 507 Pine Ave, Anna Maria
While Hometown Desserts is best known for its mouthwatering cakes and baked goods, this quaint shop also serves some incredible homemade ice cream. Located on Pine Avenue, Hometown Desserts is an ideal spot for those who want a little more than just a scoop of ice cream—whether you’re in the mood for a sundae or a slice of cake a la mode, you’ll find something to satisfy your sweet cravings here.
Known for using high-quality, fresh ingredients, the ice cream at Hometown Desserts pairs perfectly with their signature cakes and pies. For a truly indulgent experience, enjoy a scoop of their vanilla bean ice cream with a slice of their famous Key Lime Pie or Chocolate Cake.
What to Try: A slice of their Coconut Cake with a scoop of vanilla bean ice cream is an unforgettable combination.
5. Anna Maria Island Creamery & Bakery
- Location: 9801 Gulf Dr, Anna Maria
Anna Maria Island Creamery & Bakery combines the best of both worlds by offering artisanal ice cream alongside freshly baked pastries and treats. Located just a short walk from the beach, this cozy creamery prides itself on serving hand-crafted ice cream made from scratch. You’ll find unique flavors like Lemon Curd, Mango Sorbet, and even some more decadent options like Chocolate Truffle.
For those looking to enjoy their ice cream with a baked treat, the creamery’s offerings extend to homemade cookies, cupcakes, and croissants. Enjoy your treat in their quaint indoor seating area, or take it to go and enjoy it on the beach.
What to Try: Their Lemon Curd ice cream is a refreshing citrusy delight, or opt for a scoop of Mango Sorbet for something light and tropical.
6. Holy Cow Ice Cream & Other Cool Stuff
- Location: 3234 E Bay Dr, Holmes Beach
For a delightful mix of traditional and fun, head to Holy Cow Ice Cream & Other Cool Stuff in Holmes Beach. This playful ice cream shop offers a variety of flavors, including premium and soft-serve ice cream, as well as specialty sundaes, shakes, and floats. The family-friendly atmosphere and vibrant decor make Holy Cow a fun stop for all ages.
Their over-the-top sundaes, complete with whipped cream, sprinkles, and cherries, are perfect for those looking to indulge. Holy Cow’s location makes it a great spot to visit after spending a day at the beach, and with indoor and outdoor seating, you can relax and enjoy your frozen treat however you prefer.
What to Try: The Brownie Sundae is a decadent treat for chocolate lovers, and their classic Banana Split is perfect for sharing.
7. Tyler’s Homemade Ice Cream
- Location: 11904 Cortez Rd W, Cortez (Just off Anna Maria Island)
A short drive from Anna Maria Island in nearby Cortez, Tyler’s Homemade Ice Cream has been serving locals and visitors alike for over 30 years. Known for their premium, homemade ice cream made in small batches, Tyler’s offers a wide range of flavors, including fan favorites like Peanut Butter Fudge, Cappuccino Kahlua, and Birthday Cake.
Tyler’s is a hidden gem and the perfect place to stop after a day of exploring the historic fishing village of Cortez or the beautiful beaches of Anna Maria Island. Their old-fashioned ice cream counter adds to the charm, and their outdoor seating area is great for enjoying your treat in the Florida sunshine.
What to Try: Their Cappuccino Kahlua ice cream is perfect for coffee lovers, and their seasonal flavors like Pumpkin or Eggnog are great for trying something new.
A Sweet Island Escape with Once Upon A Beach
Anna Maria Island’s ice cream shops are just as charming and unique as the island itself. Whether you’re strolling along Pine Avenue, relaxing on the beach, or exploring the island with family, treating yourself to a delicious ice cream is the perfect way to savor the island’s laid-back, sweet spirit.
At Once Upon A Beach, we are here to help you create a luxurious and memorable vacation. From finding the perfect ice cream shop to suggesting local activities and attractions, we ensure your time on Anna Maria Island is as sweet as it is relaxing. So, don’t forget to take a break from the sun, grab a cone, and enjoy the island’s best frozen treats!
