Anna Maria Island is known for its stunning beaches, relaxing ambiance, and breathtaking sunsets, but it’s also home to some of the best fine dining experiences on Florida’s Gulf Coast. Whether you’re looking for a romantic evening by the ocean or a gourmet meal in an intimate setting, the dining options in and around Anna Maria Island promise a culinary journey that will delight every palate.
At Once Upon A Beach, we believe that fine dining is an integral part of any luxury vacation, and we want to help you discover the best restaurants during your stay. Here’s our curated list of the top 10 fine dining restaurants within 15 miles of Anna Maria Island that will elevate your dining experience to the next level.
1. Beach Bistro
- Location: 6600 Gulf Dr, Holmes Beach
- Distance from AMI: On Anna Maria Island
A true island icon, Beach Bistro offers a world-class dining experience with stunning views of the Gulf of Mexico. This award-winning restaurant is renowned for its impeccable service, beautiful beachfront location, and expertly crafted cuisine. Specializing in fresh seafood and gourmet dishes, Beach Bistro combines French-inspired techniques with local flavors for a luxurious meal you won’t soon forget.
What to Try: The Lobster and Lamb, a perfect pairing of local seafood and premium meat, or the famed "Bouillabaisse of the Gods."
2. Chateau Anna Maria
- Location: 5325 Marina Dr, Holmes Beach
- Distance from AMI: On Anna Maria Island
Located within the elegant Waterline Marina Resort, Chateau Anna Maria brings European sophistication to the island. The restaurant features a refined menu blending French cuisine with fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Whether you’re looking for a romantic dinner or a celebratory meal, Chateau Anna Maria offers a luxurious dining experience in a serene marina setting.
What to Try: The Filet Mignon paired with one of their exceptional wines, or the fresh, flavorful Scallops Provencal.
3. The Waterfront Restaurant
- Location: 111 S Bay Blvd, Anna Maria
- Distance from AMI: On Anna Maria Island
For a blend of casual elegance and gourmet cuisine, The Waterfront Restaurant is a must-visit. Overlooking Tampa Bay, this restaurant offers a fresh and creative menu featuring everything from succulent seafood to handcrafted cocktails. With a focus on local ingredients and seasonal flavors, The Waterfront combines stunning views with an elevated yet approachable dining experience.
What to Try: The Lobster Mac and Cheese or the Blackened Grouper Tacos, paired with a refreshing cocktail.
4. Shore LBK
- Location: 800 Broadway St, Longboat Key
- Distance from AMI: About 7 miles
Located on beautiful Longboat Key, Shore LBK offers an upscale coastal dining experience with a modern, mid-century vibe. This chic, open-air restaurant features fresh seafood, premium steaks, and creative takes on classic dishes. The stylish décor and relaxed island ambiance make it the perfect spot for a sophisticated yet relaxed evening out.
What to Try: The Tuna Poke Bowl is a fan favorite, and their Grilled Octopus is perfectly tender and flavorful.
5. Euphemia Haye
- Location: 5540 Gulf of Mexico Dr, Longboat Key
- Distance from AMI: About 10 miles
Euphemia Haye is a charming fine dining restaurant located in a converted Florida cottage, offering a unique and romantic dining experience. Known for its Old Florida charm and gourmet cuisine, Euphemia Haye features signature dishes such as Duckling, Prime Beef, and fresh seafood. After dinner, head upstairs to the Haye Loft for live music and an incredible selection of homemade desserts.
What to Try: The signature Roast Duckling or the Caribbean Snapper, and finish with their famous Banana Foster.
6. Chateau 13
- Location: 535 13th St W, Bradenton
- Distance from AMI: About 9 miles
If you’re looking for a sophisticated European dining experience, head to Chateau 13 in Bradenton. This chic, upscale restaurant offers a menu inspired by French and Mediterranean cuisine, with expertly crafted dishes and an extensive wine list. With its intimate atmosphere and impeccable service, Chateau 13 is perfect for a romantic dinner or special occasion.
What to Try: The Coq au Vin is a classic favorite, and the Pan-Seared Scallops are divine.
7. EnRich Bistro
- Location: 5629 Manatee Ave W, Bradenton
- Distance from AMI: About 5 miles
For farm-to-table dining with a modern twist, EnRich Bistro in Bradenton is a culinary standout. Chef Rich Knowles brings fresh, locally sourced ingredients to life in creative, contemporary dishes that combine Southern flair with fine dining techniques. The bistro’s warm and inviting atmosphere makes it a great spot for both casual dinners and special celebrations.
What to Try: The Braised Short Ribs are a must, and their Shrimp & Grits offers a flavorful Southern comfort twist.
8. Taverna Toscana
- Location: 5215 14th St W, Bradenton
- Distance from AMI: About 12 miles
For an authentic Italian fine dining experience, visit Taverna Toscana in Bradenton. This intimate restaurant focuses on traditional Tuscan dishes, offering handmade pastas, fresh seafood, and high-quality meats. The cozy, elegant atmosphere makes Taverna Toscana perfect for a romantic evening or a family celebration.
What to Try: The Osso Buco is tender and rich, and their Gnocchi with Gorgonzola Sauce is a must-try.
9. Ortygia
- Location: 1418 13th St W, Bradenton
- Distance from AMI: About 9 miles
Located in the heart of Bradenton’s Village of the Arts, Ortygia offers a unique fine dining experience with a focus on Sicilian and Mediterranean cuisine. Chef Gaetano Cannata brings his Sicilian roots to life through carefully crafted dishes made with fresh, local ingredients. The restaurant’s intimate setting and artistic surroundings create a one-of-a-kind dining experience.
What to Try: The Coniglio alla Siciliana (rabbit) and the homemade Gnocchi with a Sicilian twist.
10. Pier 22
- Location: 1200 1st Ave W, Bradenton
- Distance from AMI: About 10 miles
Pier 22 is a fine dining restaurant with a waterfront view, offering elegant dishes and a relaxed yet upscale atmosphere. Located on the Bradenton Riverwalk, the restaurant features a wide range of dishes, from fresh seafood to prime steaks, all expertly prepared. The ambiance is perfect for romantic dinners, celebrations, or a leisurely brunch.
What to Try: The Crab-Stuffed Shrimp and their New York Strip Steak are both highly recommended.
Experience Luxury Dining with Once Upon A Beach
When staying with Once Upon A Beach, your luxurious vacation isn’t just limited to the accommodations—it extends to every part of your experience, including dining. Whether you prefer a beachfront bistro, an intimate Tuscan meal, or a fine dining spot with stunning views, these top 10 restaurants near Anna Maria Island will provide an unforgettable culinary adventure.
Let us help you plan your dining experiences while you relax in one of our luxurious vacation rentals. Each meal will add another layer of indulgence to your perfect island getaway. Bon appétit!
